Fine Dining - Best of 2017

Published Oct 25, 2017

Does the thought of date night make you break out in cold sweats? Do you curse the heavens every time Valentine's Day raises the romantic stakes of your relationship? Don't worry, we've got you covered. These restaurants have been vetted by A-List voters and are good bets to deliver a romantic atmosphere with top notch food and service.

2017 Winner

1. Old Yarmouth Inn

Voters Love

"OYI is outstanding! Whether in the very comfortable pub, or the romantic dining room... the food is superb & the..." via Dee M.

Find It
223 Rte 6A Yarmouth MA 02675
  • Old Yarmouth Inn, Lodging, Dining, Great Meals, Cheap Eats, Bed and Breakfast, Romantic Restaurant, Fine Dining, Chowder, 223 Rte 6A Mid Cape Yarmouth MA 02675
    Nominee for: Fine Dining, Chowder
    223 Rte 6A, Mid Cape Yarmouth, MA
  • Nominee for: Fine Dining
    37 N Main St, Upper Cape Falmouth, MA
  • Scargo Cafe, Dining, Great Meals, Romantic Restaurant, Fine Dining, 799 Main St Mid Cape Dennis MA 02638
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    799 Main St, Mid Cape Dennis, MA
  • Whitman House Restaurant and Bass Tavern, Dining, Great Meals, Romantic Restaurant, Fine Dining, 7 Great Hollow Rd Outer Cape North Truro MA 02652
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    7 Great Hollow Rd, Outer Cape North Truro, MA
  • Bleu, Dining, Great Meals, French, Fine Dining, 10 Market St Upper Cape Mashpee MA 02649
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    10 Market St, Upper Cape Mashpee, MA
  • 6. C Salt
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    Upper Cape Falmouth, MA
  • Fin, Great Meals, Fine Dining, 800 Main Street Mid Cape Dennis MA 02638
    7. Fin
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    800 Main Street, Mid Cape Dennis, MA
  • Belfry Inn & Bistro, Dining, Lodging, Great Meals, Romantic Restaurant, Bed and Breakfast, Fine Dining, 8 Jarves St Upper Cape Sandwich MA 02563
    8 Jarves St, Upper Cape Sandwich, MA
  • Nominee for: Fine Dining
    17 Truro Center Road, Outer Cape East Falmouth, MA
  • Nominee for: Fine Dining
    2449 Main St, Lower Cape Brewster, MA
  • CERALDI, Great Meals, Fine Dining, 15 Kendrick Avenue Outer Cape Wellfleet MA 02667
    10. CERALDI
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    15 Kendrick Avenue, Outer Cape Wellfleet, MA
  • Yarmouth House Restaurant, Great Meals, Fine Dining, 335 Rte 28 West Yarmouth MA 02673
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    335 Rte 28, Mid Cape West Yarmouth, MA
  • 13. Gerardi's
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    Mid Cape South Yarmouth, MA
  • The Club Car, Dining Restaurants, Romantic Restaurant, 1 Main St Nantucket MA 02554
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    1 Main St, Nantucket Nantucket, MA
  • L'Alouette Bistro, Dining Restaurants, French, 787 Rte 28 Harwich Port MA 02646
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    787 Rte 28, Lower Cape Harwich Port, MA
  • Viera Restaurant, Great Meals, Fine Dining, 11 Route 28 Lower Cape West Harwich MA 02671
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    11 Route 28, Lower Cape West Harwich, MA
  • The Red Pheasant, Dining Restaurants, Romantic Restaurant, 905 Route 6A Dennis MA 02638
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    905 Route 6A, Mid Cape Dennis, MA
  • Bistro at Crowne Pointe, Dining Restaurants, Romantic Restaurant, 82 Bradford St Provincetown MA 02657
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    82 Bradford St, Outer Cape Provincetown, MA
  • undefined
    Nominee for: Fine Dining
    316 Main St, Outer Cape Wellfleet, MA
  • PB Boulangerie & Bistro, Specialty Food & Drink, Great Meals, Bakery, Fine Dining, 15 Lecount Hollow Rd Outer Cape Wellfleet MA 02667
    Nominee for: Bakery, Fine Dining
    15 Lecount Hollow Rd, Outer Cape Wellfleet, MA
  • Nominee for: Fine Dining
    52 Beach Road, Martha's Vineyard Vineyard Haven, MA
  • Sal's Place, Dining, Great Meals, Italian, Waterfront Dining, Fine Dining, Seafood, 99 Commercial St Outer Cape Provincetown MA 02657
    99 Commercial St, Outer Cape Provincetown, MA
  • Dolphin Restaurant, Great Meals, Seafood, Fine Dining, 3250 Main Street Mid Cape Barnstable MA 02630
    Nominee for: Seafood, Fine Dining
    3250 Main Street, Mid Cape Barnstable, MA
  • Nominee for: Fine Dining
    175 Bradford Street Ext, Outer Cape Provincetown, MA
  • Marshland Too Restaurant & Bakery, Dining, Cheap Eats, Breakfast, Family Restaurant, 315 Cotuit Rd Upper Cape Sandwich MA 02563
    315 Cotuit Rd, Upper Cape Sandwich, MA
Contest Overview
  • 5,726
    Total Votes
  • 2,029
  • 84

The 2017 Cape Cod A-List awards are based on more than 5,700 votes from local Cape Cod-area experts.

See the full results →

Get more from the Cape Cod A-List
Arts & Culture
Cheap Eats
Entertainment & Nightlife
Great Meals
Health & Wellness
Specialty Food & Drink
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
The Cape Cod A-List features more than 2,097 businesses competing for title of Cape Cod's best.

Connect with Cape Cod A-List