Voting Home / Specialty Food & Drink / BEST Ice Cream Shop
| Nominee | Address | Rank |
|---|---|---|
| Ben and Jerry's Scoop Shop | 50 Brackett Rd Eastham, MA | #12 |
| Cape Cod Creamery | 5 Theater Colony Rd South Yarmouth, MA | #1 |
| Cape Cod Ice Cream | 159 Ocean St Hyannis, MA | #14 |
| Emack & Bolio's | 82 Cranberry Hwy Orleans, MA | #10 |
| Four Seas Ice Cream | 360 S Main St Centerville, MA | #2 |
| Hallet's | 139 Main St Yarmouth, MA | #15 |
| Ice Cream Cafe | 5 S Orleans Rd Orleans, MA | #16 |
| Ice Cream Sandwich | 66 Rte 6A Sandwich, MA | #8 |
| Ice Cream Smuggler | 716 Main St Dennis, MA | #5 |
| Lewis Brothers Homemade Ice Cream | 310 Commercial St Provincetown, MA | #10 |
| Newport Creamery Express | 3194 Cranberry Hwy Buzzards Bay, MA | #17 |
| Ojala Farm - CLOSED | 1955 Main St Barnstable Town, MA | #17 |
| Polar Cave Ice Cream Parlour | Multiple Locations | #7 |
| Schoolhouse Ice Cream & Yogurt | 749 Rte 28 Harwich Port, MA | #13 |
| Scoopi Doo | 519 Main St West Yarmouth, MA | #17 |
| Somerset Creamery | 1268 Rte. 28A Cataumet, MA | #4 |
| Spiral Cone Ice Cream & Soft Serve | 188 Teaticket Highway/Route 28 East Falmouth, MA | #9 |
| Sundae School | 381 Lower County Rd Dennis Port, MA | #3 |
| Twin Acres | 21 Rte-6A Sandwich, MA | #6 |
| Wlelfleet Dairy Bar & Grill | 6 S Circuit Rd Wellfleet, MA | #17 |
2012 Winners + −
BEST Bakery BEST Candy Store BEST Coffee Shop BEST Farm Stand BEST Fish Market BEST Gourmet Store BEST Ice Cream Shop BEST Tea House BEST Wine Shop2008 Winners + −
BEST Bakery BEST Candy Store BEST Coffee Shop BEST Farm Stand BEST Fish Market BEST Gourmet Store BEST Ice Cream Shop BEST Tea House BEST Wine Shop
