Winner
2009 Winner

1. Sweet Tomatoes Neapolitan Pizza - CLOSED

Voters Love

"We LOVE Sweet Tomatoes pizza!!! We actually used to drive from South Yarmouth to Sandwich about once a month and get..." via spicypopcorn

Find It
791 Main Street Osterville MA 02655
  • Sweet Tomatoes Neapolitan Pizza, Dining, Pizza, 791 Main Street Mid Cape Osterville MA 02655
    Nominee for: Pizza
    791 Main Street, Mid Cape Osterville, MA
  • Two Brothers Pizza & Mexican, Dining, Cheap Eats, Pizza, Family Restaurant, Sandwich Shop, 331 Cotuit Road Upper Cape Sandwich MA 02563
    Nominee for: Pizza
    331 Cotuit Road, Upper Cape Sandwich, MA
  • Marc Anthony's Pizzeria, Dining, Cheap Eats, Pizza, 2 Onset Bay Lane Buzzards Bay MA 02532
    Nominee for: Pizza
    2 Onset Bay Lane, Buzzards Bay, MA
  • Wicked Fire Kissed Pizza, Dining, Cheap Eats, Pizza, 680 Falmouth Road Upper Cape Mashpee MA 02649
    Nominee for: Pizza
    680 Falmouth Road, Upper Cape Mashpee, MA
  • Pizzas by Evan, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 559 Rte 6A Yarmouth MA 02675
    Nominee for: Pizza
    559 Rte 6A, Mid Cape Yarmouth, MA
  • Spiritus Pizza, Dining, Pizza, 10 Seaboard Ln Mid Cape Hyannis MA 02601
    Nominee for: Pizza
    Multiple locations
  • George's Pizza House, Dining, Cheap Eats, Pizza, 564 Main Street Lower Cape Harwich Port MA 02646
    Nominee for: Pizza
    564 Main Street, Lower Cape Harwich Port, MA
  • Pizza Wave, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 3864 Falmouth Rd Marstons Mills MA 02648
    Nominee for: Pizza
    3864 Falmouth Rd, Mid Cape Marstons Mills, MA
  • Pi Pizzeria, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 11 W Creek Rd Nantucket MA 02554
    Nominee for: Pizza
    11 W Creek Rd, Nantucket Nantucket, MA
  • Chapoquoit Grill, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 410 W Falmouth Hwy Falmouth MA 02540
    Nominee for: Pizza
    410 W Falmouth Hwy, Upper Cape Falmouth, MA
  • Craigville Pizza & Mexican, Dining, Cheap Eats, Pizza, 1077 Highway 28 Mid Cape South Yarmouth MA 02664
    Nominee for: Pizza
    1077 Highway 28, Mid Cape South Yarmouth, MA
  • Palio Pizzeria, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 435 Main St Hyannis MA 02601
    Nominee for: Pizza
    435 Main St, Mid Cape Hyannis, MA
  • Pizza 1 & Subs 2, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 28 E Falmouth Hwy East Falmouth MA 02536 Falmouth Rd Marstons Mills MA 02648
    Nominee for: Pizza
    Multiple locations
  • Showtime Pizza, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 614 Main St Dennis MA 02638
    Nominee for: Pizza
    614 Main St, Mid Cape Dennis, MA
  • Laurino's Tavern, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 3668 Main St Brewster MA 02631
    Nominee for: Pizza
    3668 Main St, Lower Cape Brewster, MA
  • Kosta's Pizza, Dining, Food, Pizza, 338 E Falmouth Hwy Upper Cape East Falmouth MA 02536
    Nominee for: Pizza
    338 E Falmouth Hwy, Upper Cape East Falmouth, MA
  • Pi Pizza Bistro, Dining, Food, Pizza, 75 Davis Straits Upper Cape Falmouth MA 02540
    Nominee for: Pizza
    75 Davis Straits, Upper Cape Falmouth, MA
  • Paradise Pizza, Dining, Cheap Eats, Pizza, 74 School Street Mid Cape West Dennis MA 02670
    Nominee for: Pizza
    74 School Street, Mid Cape West Dennis, MA
  • Lattanzi's, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 19 Church St Edgartown MA 02539
    Nominee for: Pizza
    19 Church St, Martha's Vineyard Edgartown, MA
  • Fairway Restaurant &  Pizzeria, Dining, Pizza, Breakfast, 4295 State Hwy Outer Cape Eastham MA 02642
    Nominee for: Pizza, Breakfast
    4295 State Hwy, Outer Cape Eastham, MA
  • Provincetown House of Pizza, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 50 Bradford St Provincetown MA 02657
    Nominee for: Pizza
    50 Bradford St, Outer Cape Provincetown, MA
  • Brewster Pizza House, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 2655 Main St Brewster MA 02631
    Nominee for: Pizza
    2655 Main St, Lower Cape Brewster, MA
  • Buncey's Pizza, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 894 Route 134 South Dennis MA 02660
    Nominee for: Pizza
    894 Route 134, Mid Cape South Dennis, MA
  • Sophie T's Pizza, Dining Restaurants, Pizza, 7 Daves St Nantucket MA 02554
    Nominee for: Pizza
    7 Daves St, Nantucket Nantucket, MA
  • Lil' Kim's Pizza and Smoothies, Dining, Food, Pizza, 252 Shore Dr Upper Cape New Seabury MA 02649
    Nominee for: Pizza
    252 Shore Dr, Upper Cape New Seabury, MA
Contest Overview
  • 7,925
    Total Votes
  • 3,411
    Voters
  • 75
    Winners

The 2009 Cape Cod A-List awards are based on more than 7,900 votes from local Cape Cod-area experts.

See the full results →

Get more from the Cape Cod A-List
Sections
Arts & Culture
Dining
Entertainment & Nightlife
Health & Wellness
Lodging
Outdoors
Shopping
Specialty Food & Drink
Weddings
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
Sitemap
Information
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
About
The Cape Cod A-List features more than 2,098 businesses competing for title of Cape Cod's best.

Connect with Cape Cod A-List

@CapeCodAList