Seafood - Best of 2012

Published May 10, 2012

If it comes from the sea, these restaurants know how to serve it right! Who's the best?

Winner
2012 Winner

1. The Lobster Pot

Voters Love

"This is a fun place to go for lobster. A great tip I heard (and have now done twice) is to split the Clambake with..." via demoOC

Find It
321 Commercial St Provincetown MA 02657
  • The Lobster Pot, Dining, Great Meals, Cheap Eats, Waterfront Dining, Seafood, Lobster Roll, Family Restaurant, 321 Commercial St Outer Cape Provincetown MA 02657
    321 Commercial St, Outer Cape Provincetown, MA
  • Brewster Fish House, Dining, Great Meals, Seafood, 2208 Main St Lower Cape Brewster MA 02631
    Nominee for: Seafood
    2208 Main St, Lower Cape Brewster, MA
  • Quarterdeck Restaurant, Dining, Great Meals, Cheap Eats, Seafood, Chowder, 164 Main St Upper Cape Falmouth MA 02540
    Nominee for: Seafood
    164 Main St, Upper Cape Falmouth, MA
  • Wimpy's Seafood Cafe & Market, Dining, Great Meals, Cheap Eats, Seafood, Chowder, 752 Main St Mid Cape Osterville MA 02655
    Nominee for: Seafood
    752 Main St, Mid Cape Osterville, MA
  • Mac's Shack, Dining, Great Meals, Seafood, Raw Bar, 91 Commercial St Outer Cape Wellfleet MA 02667
    Nominee for: Seafood
    91 Commercial St, Outer Cape Wellfleet, MA
  • Academy Ocean Grille, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 2 Academy Pl Orleans MA 02653
    Nominee for: Seafood
    2 Academy Pl, Lower Cape Orleans, MA
  • Oliver's, Dining, Great Meals, Seafood, New American, Pizza, Rte 6A & Bray Farm Rd S Mid Cape Yarmouth MA 02675
    Nominee for: Seafood
    Rte 6A & Bray Farm Rd S, Mid Cape Yarmouth, MA
  • Shuckers, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 91 Water St Woods Hole MA 02543
    Nominee for: Seafood
    91 Water St, Upper Cape Woods Hole, MA
  • Oysters Too, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 876 E Falmouth Hwy East Falmouth MA 02536
    Nominee for: Seafood
    876 E Falmouth Hwy, Upper Cape East Falmouth, MA
  • The Wicked Oyster, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 50 Main St Wellfleet MA 02667
    Nominee for: Seafood
    50 Main St, Outer Cape Wellfleet, MA
  • The Port, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 541 Route 28 Harwich Port MA 02646
    10. The Port
    Nominee for: Seafood
    541 Route 28, Lower Cape Harwich Port, MA
  • Moby Dick's Restaurant, Great Meals, Seafood, 3225 State Highway Wellfleet MA 02667
    Nominee for: Seafood
    3225 State Highway, Outer Cape Wellfleet, MA
  • Original Seafood Restaurant, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 527 Main St Dennis Port MA 02639
    Nominee for: Seafood
    527 Main St, Mid Cape Dennis Port, MA
  • Arties Cafe, Dining, Great Meals, Seafood, Sandwich Shop, 281 Main St Upper Cape Falmouth MA 02540
    Nominee for: Seafood
    281 Main St, Upper Cape Falmouth, MA
  • Naked Oyster, Dining, Great Meals, Seafood, Raw Bar, 20 Independence Dr Mid Cape Hyannis MA 02601
    Nominee for: Seafood
    20 Independence Dr, Mid Cape Hyannis, MA
  • Van Rensselaer's Restaurant, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 1019 Route 6 Wellfleet MA 02667
    Nominee for: Seafood
    1019 Route 6, Outer Cape Wellfleet, MA
  • The Oyster Company Raw Bar & Grille, Great Meals, Seafood, Raw Bar, 202 Depot St Dennis Port MA 02639
    Nominee for: Seafood
    202 Depot St, Mid Cape Dennis Port, MA
  • Mahoney's Atlantic Bar & Grill, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 28 Main St Orleans MA 02653
    Nominee for: Seafood
    28 Main St, Lower Cape Orleans, MA
  • Cape Sea Grille, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 31 Sea St, P.O. Box 414 Harwich Port MA 02646
    Nominee for: Seafood
    31 Sea St, P.O. Box 414, Lower Cape Harwich Port, MA
  • Lobster Shanty, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 2905 State Hwy Eastham MA 02642
    Nominee for: Seafood
    2905 State Hwy, Outer Cape Eastham, MA
  • The SeaGrille, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 45 Sparks Ave Nantucket MA 02554
    Nominee for: Seafood
    45 Sparks Ave, Nantucket Nantucket, MA
  • Salty's, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 540 Main Street, Rt. 28 South Yarmouth MA 02664
    Nominee for: Seafood
    540 Main Street, Rt. 28, Mid Cape South Yarmouth, MA
  • Finely J.P.'s Restaurant, Dining Restaurants, Seafood, 554 Rte 6 Wellfleet MA 02667
    Nominee for: Seafood
    554 Rte 6, Outer Cape Wellfleet, MA
  • Patio American Grill, Dining Nightlife Restaurants, Breakfast Cocktails New American Seafood, 328 Commercial St Provincetown MA 02657
    Nominee for: Seafood
    328 Commercial St, Outer Cape Provincetown, MA
  • The Lobster Trap, Specialty Food & Drink, Dining, Cheap Eats, Fish Market, Seafood, Lobster Roll, Clam Shack, 290 Shore Road Upper Cape Buzzards Bay MA 02532
    Multiple locations
Contest Overview
  • 10,270
    Total Votes
  • 3,365
    Voters
  • 63
    Winners

The 2012 Cape Cod A-List awards are based on more than 10,000 votes from local Cape Cod-area experts.

See the full results →

Get more from the Cape Cod A-List
Sections
Arts & Culture
Dining
Entertainment & Nightlife
Health & Wellness
Lodging
Outdoors
Shopping
Specialty Food & Drink
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
Sitemap
Information
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
About
The Cape Cod A-List features more than 2,097 businesses competing for title of Cape Cod's best.

Connect with Cape Cod A-List

@CapeCodAList